Key takeaways

• You are not obliged to remain with St. James’s Place (SJP) indefinitely, and pensions and investments can often be transferred to another provider or adviser.
• Before moving, it is important to understand exactly what you hold, what you are paying and whether any exit or early withdrawal charges still apply to your particular investments.
• Charges are important, but they should not be considered in isolation. Investment performance, diversification, financial planning, service and the value of ongoing advice all matter.
• Moving away from SJP does not automatically mean that you should cash in your investments. In many cases, investments can be transferred as part of a properly planned move.
• An independent financial adviser can review the wider market rather than being restricted to one provider’s products and investment solutions.
• For clients in Cirencester, Swindon, Cricklade and the surrounding Cotswolds and Wiltshire areas, obtaining a second opinion can be relatively straightforward — although we also advise clients throughout the UK.

If you have a pension or investment with St. James’s Place, you may have recently found yourself asking a fairly simple question:

Should I stay with SJP, or would I be better off somewhere else?

It is a question we are increasingly asked by investors who want to understand their charges, review investment performance or simply find out whether they have other options.

The answer will not be the same for everyone.

St. James’s Place is one of the UK’s largest wealth management businesses and advises more than one million clients. Many clients have longstanding relationships with their SJP adviser and may be perfectly happy with the service they receive.

Others, however, may have concerns about cost, investment choice, performance or whether the advice they receive still represents good value.

The key point is this:

You do have a choice.

Having an SJP pension, ISA, investment bond or investment portfolio does not mean you cannot review your arrangements or seek advice elsewhere.

At Mather & Murray Financial, we are independent financial advisers based in Cricklade, conveniently located between Swindon and Cirencester, with SJP’s head office just a short distance away in Cirencester.

We therefore speak to a number of people locally who either currently invest through SJP or have done so previously.

If you are considering your options, here are the main things we believe you should look at before making any decisions.

1. Find Out Exactly What You Have With SJP

This sounds obvious, but it should always be the starting point.

Over the years, clients can accumulate several different arrangements, potentially including:

• Personal pensions
• Retirement accounts
• Stocks & Shares ISAs
• Unit trusts
• Investment bonds
• Trust-based investments

Different products can have different charges, tax implications and transfer rules.

Before recommending any change, an adviser should establish exactly what you own and obtain up-to-date information about each arrangement.

This is particularly important if your investments have been held for many years, as the terms applying to an older SJP product may be different from those available to a new investor today.

The question should therefore not simply be:

“Should I leave SJP?”

It should be:

“Is each of my existing arrangements still the most suitable way of achieving what I want from my money?”

That is a much more useful conversation.

2. Understand What You Are Actually Paying

Charges are one of the biggest reasons investors start reviewing their financial arrangements.

But comparing charges is not always as straightforward as comparing one percentage with another.

There can potentially be separate costs for:

• Financial advice
• The investment product or platform
• Investment fund management
• Underlying investment costs and transaction costs

SJP changed its charging structure in 2025, separating its advice, product and fund charges to make the different components easier to identify.

That is useful, but investors should still look at the total cost of investing, rather than focusing on one individual element.

For example, you might ask:

What percentage of my portfolio am I paying each year in total?

What service am I receiving in return?

How often is my financial plan reviewed?

Are my investments being actively monitored?

Am I receiving tax planning advice?

Is my adviser considering my pensions, investments, retirement plans and estate planning together?

Ultimately, a financial adviser charging more can potentially represent better value if they provide significantly better planning and service.

Equally, paying substantial ongoing fees without receiving meaningful ongoing advice should prompt questions.

The issue is therefore not simply whether something is “expensive”.

The real question is:

Am I receiving good value for the money I am paying?

3. Check Whether You Would Pay Anything to Leave SJP

This is particularly important.

SJP introduced a new charging structure in August 2025, and Early Withdrawal Charges no longer apply to new investments made under the new arrangements.

However, clients with older investments may be in a different position.

Depending on when and how money was originally invested, there may still be historic charging arrangements that need to be considered.

You should therefore obtain confirmation of:

• Your current fund value
• Your current transfer value
• Any early withdrawal or exit charges
• When any applicable charges expire
• Whether different contributions are subject to different terms

In some cases, the sensible decision may be to transfer immediately.

In others, it could potentially be better to wait until an existing charge reduces or disappears.

A proper review should calculate the financial implications rather than simply assuming that moving — or staying — is automatically the right answer.

4. Review Investment Performance Properly

Another common reason people approach us is concern about investment performance.

Again, this needs careful analysis.

It is rarely fair to look at an investment return in isolation and conclude that it has either performed well or badly.

You need an appropriate comparison.

That means considering factors such as:

• The level of investment risk you agreed to take
• The asset allocation of your portfolio
• The period over which you have been invested
• How comparable investments performed
• The effect of charges
• Whether your attitude to risk or circumstances have changed

An investor in a cautious portfolio should not expect the same returns as somebody investing almost entirely in global equities.

But equally, if two portfolios have taken broadly similar levels of risk over a long period, comparing their net returns can be extremely useful.

We believe investment performance should therefore be reviewed alongside both risk and cost.

The goal is not to find the fund that performed best last year.

It is to build an investment strategy appropriate for your objectives that you can realistically maintain over the long term.

5. Ask Whether You Have Enough Investment Choice

One of the fundamental differences between St. James’s Place and an independent financial adviser is the investment universe available when recommendations are made.

An independent financial adviser is able to consider appropriate solutions from across the wider market when making recommendations.

This does not automatically mean that an independent adviser will always recommend something better.

What it does mean is that they can assess whether other platforms, investment managers, funds or solutions may be more suitable for you.

For some investors, having a restricted range of solutions may not be a problem.

For others — particularly those with larger or more complex portfolios — access to a broader range of investment options may be attractive.

That could potentially include:

• Managed portfolios
• Passive investment strategies
• Active funds
• Discretionary fund management
• Specialist investments
• Ethical or ESG portfolios
• Different pension and investment platforms

The appropriate solution will depend on your circumstances.

The important point is that the recommendation should start with what you need, rather than with a predetermined product.

6. Consider the Financial Planning, Not Just the Investments

This is perhaps the most important point of all.

Good financial advice should involve much more than selecting investment funds.

A proper financial plan might consider:

• When you want to retire
• How much income you will need
• Whether you are making full use of pension allowances
• ISA planning
• Capital Gains Tax
• Income Tax
• Inheritance Tax
• Trust planning
• Protection for you and your family
• Passing wealth between generations
• How much investment risk you genuinely need to take

For many clients, the investment portfolio is simply one part of a much bigger picture.

Someone approaching retirement, for example, may need advice on how to draw income tax-efficiently from a combination of pensions, ISAs and other investments.

A business owner might need advice about pension contributions, company investments and extracting wealth from their business.

A family with a significant estate may need to consider inheritance tax and estate planning alongside their investments.

Therefore, before changing adviser, ask yourself:

Am I receiving investment management, or am I receiving genuine financial planning?

There is an important difference.

7. Do I Have to Sell Everything to Leave SJP?

Not necessarily.

The exact process depends on the products and investments you hold.

Some investments may be capable of being transferred without you personally withdrawing the money, while in other circumstances investments may need to be sold and the proceeds transferred as cash before being reinvested.

Pensions in particular should normally be approached carefully.

Transferring a pension is very different from withdrawing money from one.

A pension-to-pension transfer will generally keep the money within the pension environment, whereas personally withdrawing pension benefits can have significant tax consequences.

You should therefore take advice before making any withdrawals simply because you want to move away from your existing provider.

The same applies to investment bonds and other investments where surrendering an arrangement could have tax consequences.

Review first. Act second.

8. Should I Transfer My SJP Pension?

There is no universal answer.

A transfer could potentially be appropriate where another arrangement offers a combination of:

• Lower or more transparent charges
• Greater investment choice
• Improved pension flexibility
• Better retirement planning
• A more suitable investment strategy
• Better ongoing service

But transferring may not be appropriate where valuable benefits would be lost or the costs of moving outweigh the potential benefits.

That is precisely why we believe a pension review should start with your existing plan.

A good adviser should be prepared to recommend that you leave something exactly where it is when that is genuinely the best option.

9. Should I Leave My SJP Adviser?

It is important to separate the individual adviser from the organisation.

You may have an excellent relationship with your SJP Partner.

You may trust them, enjoy working with them and believe you receive excellent service.

That has genuine value.

Moving your investments should not be based purely on a newspaper headline or somebody else’s experience.

Equally, loyalty should not prevent you from occasionally asking whether your arrangements remain competitive and suitable.

There is nothing wrong with getting a second opinion.

You would probably obtain several quotes before undertaking major work on your home.

Many people compare mortgage rates before remortgaging.

Yet investment portfolios and pensions can be worth hundreds of thousands — or even millions — of pounds, and may remain with the same provider for decades without ever being independently reviewed.

We think periodically reviewing those arrangements is simply sensible financial planning.

“We have previously looked in detail at some of the criticism and concerns surrounding St. James’s Place.”

SJP or an Independent Financial Adviser: What’s the Difference?

One of the questions people often search for is:

“What is the difference between SJP and an independent financial adviser?”

The main distinction is the scope of the advice.

An independent financial adviser can consider suitable products and providers from across the wider market.

This means we can assess different pension providers, investment platforms and investment solutions when deciding what is appropriate.

At Mather & Murray Financial, our starting point is not:

“Which of our products should you buy?”

It is:

“What are you trying to achieve?”

From there, we can consider the most appropriate way of helping you achieve it.

Sometimes that may mean moving an existing investment.

Sometimes it may mean changing the investment strategy but retaining an existing arrangement.

And sometimes the best advice may be to do nothing at all.

Looking for an Independent Review of Your SJP Investments?

If you are an existing St. James’s Place client and you are unsure whether your pension or investments remain right for you, we can provide an independent review.

Our advisers can look at your existing arrangements and help you understand:

• What you currently hold
• What charges you are paying
• Whether any exit or early withdrawal charges apply
• How your investments have performed
• The level of risk you are taking
• Whether alternative arrangements should be considered
• How your investments fit into your wider financial plans

You can then make an informed decision.

There is no assumption that you need to transfer simply because you ask us to review your arrangements.

Independent Financial Advice Near SJP’s Cirencester Head Office

Mather & Murray Financial is based in Cricklade, between Cirencester and Swindon, putting us in a particularly convenient location for clients across the local area.

We work with clients in:

• Cirencester
• Swindon
• Cricklade
• The Cotswolds
• Wiltshire
• Gloucestershire
• Bristol
• Cheltenham
• And throughout the UK

Meetings can take place face-to-face, by telephone or by video call.

So whether you have £50,000 invested with SJP or a much larger portfolio accumulated over many years, you can speak to an independent adviser and understand your options before deciding what to do next.

Thinking About Leaving St. James’s Place?

Before making any decisions, speak to us for an independent second opinion.

We can review your SJP pensions and investments, explain your existing charges and help you understand whether remaining where you are — or considering an alternative — is likely to be the better option for you.

Speak to Mather & Murray Financial today to arrange an initial conversation with one of our independent financial advisers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I leave St. James’s Place?

Yes. Depending on the type of pension or investment you hold, it may be possible to transfer your arrangement to another provider. You should check the terms of your existing investments and any applicable charges before proceeding.

Does SJP charge you to leave?

SJP removed Early Withdrawal Charges for new investments under its revised charging structure introduced in 2025. However, older investments may be subject to different historic terms, so your individual transfer or withdrawal position should be checked before making a decision.

Can I transfer my SJP pension to another provider?

In many circumstances, yes. However, the suitability of transferring will depend on the type of pension, its benefits, charges and your personal circumstances. Pension transfers should be assessed carefully before proceeding.

Can an independent financial adviser review my SJP pension?

Yes. An independent financial adviser can obtain information about your existing arrangements with your authority, review the benefits and charges and advise whether retaining or transferring the pension is appropriate.

Is an independent financial adviser cheaper than SJP?

Not necessarily. Charges vary between advisers, investment platforms and investment strategies. The appropriate comparison is the total cost of the service and the value you receive for that cost.

Should I leave SJP because of poor investment performance?

Investment performance should be assessed carefully against an appropriate benchmark and the level of risk taken. A period of disappointing performance does not automatically mean that transferring is appropriate.

Where can I find an independent financial adviser near SJP in Cirencester?

Mather & Murray Financial is based in Cricklade, between Cirencester and Swindon. We provide independent financial advice to clients across Wiltshire, Gloucestershire and the Cotswolds, as well as advising clients throughout the UK.

Important information: The value of investments can fall as well as rise and you may get back less than you invested. Pension and investment recommendations should be based on your individual circumstances. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may be subject to change.